During election periods, the financial markets often experience heightened volatility, which tempts many traders to employ strategies they believe will guarantee profits. One such strategy frequently touted across social media platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube involves creating a straddle by purchasing both call and put options. The idea behind this approach is that the market will likely move significantly in one direction following the election results, allowing traders to profit from the move irrespective of its direction. However, while this strategy seems foolproof in theory, backtesting it on historical election data reveals a more complex reality.

To illustrate this, let’s revisit the 2019 Indian general elections and analyze the performance of a straddle strategy on the Bank Nifty index. On May 23, 2019, the day the election results were announced, Bank Nifty experienced a significant move, rising by approximately 4.44%, equivalent to a 1400-point increase. This kind of movement is rare on regular trading days, and such a scenario might initially suggest a perfect opportunity for the straddle strategy to succeed. If one had bought both call and put options at the market open, they might expect to capitalize on this substantial market movement. But to understand the real impact, we need to delve deeper into the numbers and market dynamics.

The crux of the straddle strategy lies in implied volatility (IV), which often skyrockets during high-stakes events like elections. On May 23, 2019, the IV for at-the-money options on Bank Nifty was notably high: around 113 for calls and 147 for puts, far above the usual range of 10-15. This elevated IV means that options are priced significantly higher than usual. At the market open, the at-the-money call option was priced at ₹474 and the put option at ₹387. A trader following the straddle strategy would thus spend a considerable amount, betting on a substantial market move.

The initial analysis might suggest that with Bank Nifty moving by 4.44%, such a strategy would yield profits. However, the reality is more nuanced due to the concept of IV crush. As the election results become clear and market uncertainty diminishes, IV tends to drop sharply. Within just 15 minutes of market opening, the IV for the call option dropped from 113 to 90, and the IV for the put option also fell significantly. This rapid decline in IV, known as IV crush, dramatically reduces the value of the options purchased.

To see the impact, consider the straddle’s profit and loss dynamics. Immediately after the market opened, the trader might notice an initial loss due to the sharp IV decline. Despite the 4.44% move in Bank Nifty, the IV crash caused the combined value of the options to drop, leading to a loss of ₹2700 within the first 15 minutes. This occurs because the options’ premium paid at the high IV levels doesn’t justify the actual movement in the underlying asset once the IV drops.

As the day progresses and the market absorbs the election results, the situation becomes clearer. The implied volatility, which had been priced in due to the uncertainty of the election outcome, decreases further, continuing to erode the options’ value. By the end of the trading session, even with Bank Nifty’s significant upward move, the expected profits from the straddle strategy would not materialize due to the substantial initial cost and subsequent IV crush. This highlights a critical point: the high cost of options during periods of elevated IV and the rapid depreciation of these options once the event uncertainty diminishes can turn seemingly profitable strategies into losing ones.

For traders looking to capitalize on election-driven market movements, understanding IV and its impact on options pricing is crucial. Simply buying call and put options in anticipation of a significant move isn’t sufficient. It’s essential to account for the elevated costs due to high IV and the likelihood of an IV crush following the event, which can severely impact the profitability of such trades.

Instead of blindly following popular strategies on social media, traders should focus on thorough research and backtesting. Historical data analysis provides invaluable insights into market behavior during similar past events. In the case of the 2019 elections, a detailed backtest reveals that despite a significant market move, the high IV environment and subsequent IV crush would have made a straddle strategy less profitable or even resulted in losses.

Moreover, understanding market sentiment and using more nuanced strategies might yield better results. For instance, strategies like calendar spreads or iron condors, which can benefit from changes in IV and time decay, might be more appropriate in such scenarios. These strategies involve selling options to take advantage of the high premiums rather than buying them, thus capitalizing on the IV drop.

Backtesting is a crucial part of any trading strategy, allowing you to understand how a particular strategy would have performed in the past, thereby giving insights into its potential future performance. In this context, let’s delve into a specific instance involving the Nifty index, focusing on the expiry of May 23, 2019. This date is notable because it coincides with an election result day, which typically brings significant market volatility.

On May 23, 2019, the Nifty options chain showed an expiry, and examining the option chain from May 9 to May 16 gives us a snapshot of the market’s behavior leading up to that critical day. Let’s analyze the potential losses and gains experienced by traders during this period, and discuss the merits of different trading strategies like straddle and directional trades.

Initially, if we look at the option chain data, we notice that traders holding the 10800 strike price options faced significant challenges. There were instances where losses escalated dramatically. For example, a loss of ₹1 crore could shrink to ₹50 lakh within the first 15 minutes of trading due to rapid market movements. This underscores the inherent volatility and the risks of trading on such significant days. The initial price movement of around ₹24,000 quickly adjusted to ₹13,000, indicating how swiftly the market can turn, impacting traders’ positions substantially.

Given this volatility, it is often recommended to favor directional trades over straddles on such high-stakes days. A straddle involves buying both a call and a put option at the same strike price, betting on significant movement in either direction. However, this strategy can be risky if the market doesn’t move enough to cover the premiums paid for both options. Instead, identifying the correct market direction and placing a directional trade, especially with out-of-the-money (OTM) options, can be more beneficial. This is because if the market moves significantly in the expected direction, the profits from OTM options can be substantial.

The market on election days can be particularly deceptive. It might show signs of moving in one direction, only to reverse later, adding to the challenge of identifying the right trade. This situation requires traders to have robust strategies, including effective stop-loss mechanismsand a solid understanding of price action. Trading on election days isn’t mandatory; the market remains open throughout the year, offering numerous opportunities to make money under less volatile conditions.

Looking back at previous elections, for instance, the 2014 election, the market moved by 8% in a single day. This kind of movement provides a lucrative opportunity for traders who can correctly predict the direction. However, it also involves high risk due to the potential for rapid decay in options premiums, which can erode profits quickly if the market doesn’t move as anticipated.

On May 16, 2014, the market experienced a significant intraday volatility with the Nifty moving by 5.68%. For a trader who correctly identified this movement, the profits could be substantial. However, being able to hold onto the position amidst such volatility is challenging. The same day also saw the Bank Nifty moving by 8%, further illustrating the potential for significant gains if the market direction is correctly predicted.

In trading, especially on days with expected high volatility, it’s essential to choose the right expiry. When the implied volatility (IV) is high, premiums for options can spike even if the market doesn’t move significantly, leading to potential losses if not managed correctly. Therefore, making a straddle or strangle trade when the market is within a range can be more effective. For instance, observing the Nifty in a defined range, where it oscillates between certain levels, can provide clues for making profitable trades.

If one decides to trade on days like election results, managing the trade with careful planning is crucial. Setting a stop-loss on the combined premium is one approach. For example, if a trader has invested ₹1 lakh, setting a stop-loss at ₹30,000-₹40,000 can help manage potential losses. This means if the combined premium starts increasing due to a spike in IV or a significant market movement, the trade can be exited to prevent further losses.

Traders must also consider scaling out of positions to secure profits. If the target is to achieve ₹1 lakh profit, booking half the quantity at ₹50,000-₹60,000 can be a prudent strategy. This way, if the market makes a significant move later, the remaining position can still yield substantial profits, while minimizing the risk of a complete loss.

In conclusion, backtesting and careful planning are essential for successful trading, especially on high-volatility days like election results. While there are significant opportunities for profit, the risks are equally high. By understanding market behavior, choosing the right strategies, and managing trades effectively, traders can improve their chances of success. This involves a balance of identifying market direction, using stop-loss mechanisms, and knowing when to book profits. Trading on less volatile days and within defined ranges can also be more advantageous, providing a safer environment to apply strategies like straddles and strangles.

Start Trading in the Share Market: 👉 Open a Free Demat Account on Upstox: https://bit.ly/DematAcUpstox

– NO AMC Charges for Lifetime. Start earning up to Rs 1200 per referral.


Open a Free Demat Account on Angel One: https://bit.ly/Angel1Offer

India’s biggest stock broker offers the cheapest brokerage rates for futures and options, commodity trading, equity, and mutual funds.


Open Free Demat Account on Dhan: https://bit.ly/DhanLatestOffer

Experience lightning-fast online stock trading and investing in India. Trade and invest in Stocks, F&O, Currencies, Commodities, ETFs, and IPO


Open Free Demat Account on Fyers: https://bit.ly/FyersOffer